banner

Taxes vs Humanity, Immigration vs Life, and The Winner Is?

My Dad would always say to me; “Get your own house in order before you worry about anyone else’s”.

This has been ringing more and more true for me as late.

It seems to me, we (Americans) have become increasingly vocal with our discontent. We are complaining about government spending, about healthcare, about immigration, about the big bad banks, about taxes, Obama, “Socialism” and more. An entire movement has sprouted up (The Tea Party) railing against what they see as social injustice and the ever growing control of the federal government. We seem to be growing angrier and angrier, demanding change and expressing our discontent with much around us. We seem to be mad at everyone; immigrants, Muslims, politicians, Democrats and Republicans alike, the President, CEO’s, the Pope, the oil companies, the media and more, no one has escaped our wrath of late.

In all this anger I think we are losing something far more important than all those things, our humanity.

A man died the other day. He was stabbed while trying to save a woman from being robbed. He lay dying on a New York street for almost two hours while as many as 25 people walked by. Some took pictures, others rolled him over saw blood and left. No one extended him the help he extended to the woman who was being robbed.

Have we become so self-absorbed we have abandoned our commitment to help thy neighbor? In our race to accumulate material things, do we no longer embrace the good Samaritan in ourselves? Is community now defined as those we know, those closest to us? Are the strangers who live next to us, or down the street, or even in the ally less valuable because we don’t know them?

Hugo Alfredo Tale-Yax was an immigrant from Nicaragua. He was homeless. A woman was being mugged. He knew what to do. He tried to help and we left him to die in the street. It’s sad. We are better than that.

Do we need to address government spending. Yes. Could we have better representation in Washington? Yes. Are healthcare, immigration, the economy, education and the environment important? Yes. They aren’t, however, as important as our own humanity.

We seem angry these days. I can’t help but wonder if it’s missed placed anger.

What do we have to be so angry about? Are we not surprised no one would help Hugo and that scares us? Are we subconsciously aware of a diminishing lack of empathy in our country? Is our anger rooted in the feeling we are loosing parts of our humanity? Do our fears mis-guide us? Do they create a miss-placed anger?

Hugo had the right value system. He tried to help. What about the rest of us?

The next time we feel angry and decide to march on Washington to defeat healthcare, before we let our anger drive us to join the Tea Party or the NRA, or ACORN, we might want to take a look a little closer to home. We are this country. You, me, and Hugo. We get to make a difference. The values we embrace are ours to enforce. We have the power through our interaction with others to make change. Yelling out of anger to get OTHER’s to make a difference only moves us further away from one another. Yelling out of anger for others to fix the problem doesn’t absolve us of responsibility. We only think it does.

Only a week after Arizona passed a strict illegal immigration bill to keep illigal immigrants out of this country, an illegal immigrant saved a woman’s life. This illegal immigrant demonstrated the values the American citizens who walked by as he bled to death, couldn’t.

My dad was absolutely right. We need to get our own house in order before we worry about anyone else’s.

  • http://salesandmanagementblog.com Paul McCord

    Jim,

    I would like to unhesitatingly support your point of view as expressed in your post, but I can’t. I think your logic is flawed. The implication is that those who are expressing displeasure are by definition not expressing their humanity or are being anti-humane. I think it far more likely those who walked by the individual dying on the street are also those who have little or no involvement in anything going on in their community.

    I think those who are expressing their frustration with government are the ones expressing deep, sincere humanity—seeking to not burden their children with crippling government debt; seeking to preserve a free country for future generations; seeking to preserve the most dynamic country that has created more freedom and more wealth for more people than any country in history; seeking to maintain a country that is so vibrant and full of opportunity that men and women around the world are willing to wait years, other willing to risk death to get here.

    I also think your broad generalizations are a great and very serious part of the intentional or unintentional misunderstanding in the country. Anger at Muslims? No. Anger at Fundamentalist Islamists seeking to kill Westerners? You bet. Anger at immigrants? No. Anger with a government that has no intention of protecting our borders against illegal immigrants? Absolutely. Words are important and generalizing all Muslims or all immigrants contributes to the idea that the people seeking real, substantial change are racist which is far from the truth and is the straw man used by politicians to discredit those seeking government accountability. Likewise generalizing that Americans are losing their humanity based on a few specific examples creates a impression that just isn’t correct. I can take a few examples and generalize anything I choose—that all cats are black, that all men are fat, that all cars are blue—all I have to do is line up a number of examples and ignore all those instances that fit my generalization.

    I agree that there is something of a deadening of the human heart—easily demonstrated on almost any forum on the internet can say anything they choose in total anonymity. And, yes, there are some on both the left and right who will take advantage of the situation to seek their own personal agenda. But to intentionally or unintentionally equate those who are seeking change in the government with a loss of humanity is a false and dangerous dichotomy.

    Paul

  • http://asalesguy.com Keenan

    Disagreement is MORE than acceptable. I'm married. Sometimes my wife agrees with me, other times she thinks I'm crazy. So if I can't agree with my wife all the time, I certainly don't expect my readers to agree with me.

    That being said, on a micro level I agree with you Paul. There are no absolutes in this world. However, there are appropriate generalizations. I believe generalizing with companies, and countries is appropriate. There are just too many people to be absolute.

    The thesis of my post is that the majority of our community action is targeted at issues that could be argued are far less important than our personal engagement and commit to each other.

    The “energy” we as Americans exert seems to me to rarely embrace the humanity side of things. This is not the first time we've ignored the plight of others and watched them die.

    Rightfully or wrongfully we are the stories we create. As of late the stories have not been of the humanitarian kind, but rather expression of anger.

    Paul, I don't equate those who are seeking change in the government as loss of humanity, I suggest those who prioritize the change in government over humanity as a loss. WE need to do more ourselves, rather than expecting others to do it for us.

    I believe that a real transformation happening, and I feel it's not a good one.

    Great comment Paul,

    thanks